How Do Car Accident Settlements Work?

Wisconsin Personal Injury Lawyers » How Do Car Accident Settlements Work? Latest News

Dealing with a car accident can feel overwhelming. Understanding how settlements work can also be confusing. A car accident lawyer can provide the advice you need to feel more confident and informed as you move forward. Seek a free consultation with an attorney in your area and learn more about a possible settlement in your case.

What is a Car Accident Settlement?

A car accident settlement is an agreement between an injured person and the insurance company or the at-fault party. It compensates for damages and injuries from the accident. Settlements cover costs like medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. They help avoid going to court.

Why Do Insurance Companies Offer Low Settlements?

Insurance companies are big businesses that need to make money. When accidents happen, and people file valid claims for injuries or damaged property, insurance companies must give some of their money away. But, if they pay out too much money all the time, they won’t have as many profits.

So, they often start by offering less money than what might be fair. They hope people will accept this smaller amount to settle the matter quickly.

Here are a few reasons why this happens:

  • Saving Money: The main reason is that insurance companies want to save money. By offering less money at first, they hope you’ll take it, and they can avoid paying more later.
  • Quick Deals: Sometimes, people might accept a low offer because they need money fast. Insurance companies know this and use it to their advantage.
  • Testing What You Know: If you’re unsure how much your claim is worth, you might accept a low offer. Insurance companies might start low to see if you understand the true value of your claim.
  • Avoiding More Work: If they can settle quickly, insurance companies don’t have to spend more time and effort on your claim. This is another reason they might offer a lower amount at first.

This is why it’s extremely important to talk to a car accident lawyer before you say yes to any offer. A car accident lawyer can help ensure you get a fair amount that covers everything you need after an accident, like fixing your car or paying medical bills.

The Settlement Process

The settlement process typically involves several key steps:

Claim Filing

The journey begins with filing a claim with the insurance company. In this step, you must give a full report of the accident. This includes how it happened, your injuries, and any damage to your property. Collect all needed documents, like medical records and repair costs, to prove your claim.


After your claim is filed, the insurance company will investigate to verify the details of the accident. This process involves reviewing the accident report. It also includes examining the damage to property and assessing any reported physical injuries. The insurance adjuster may also interview witnesses and review medical records. This investigation helps the insurance company determine who is responsible and how much is covered.

Demand Letter

Once your damages have been assessed, your legal representative will draft a demand letter to the insurance company. This letter outlines:

  • The details of the accident
  • Your injuries
  • The damages incurred
  • The compensation amount you are seeking

A demand letter asks for money to cover your losses. A car accident lawyer can write this letter to explain how the accident affected you and why you need compensation.


After you send a demand letter, the insurance company may make a counteroffer to start negotiating. You and the company will discuss and agree on a fair compensation amount.

This stage requires patience and good negotiation skills to reach a fair settlement. A car accident lawyer can handle these negotiations for you, aiming for the best result.

Settlement Agreement

If both parties agree on the compensation amount, the next step is to draft a settlement agreement. This legal document outlines the settlement terms, including the agreed-upon compensation amount.

By signing this agreement, you agree not to pursue any further claims related to the accident in exchange for the settlement amount. Reviewing this agreement carefully with legal counsel ensures your rights are fully protected.


Man and woman seated, attentively reading a letter regarding husband's neck injury.

The final step in the settlement process is receiving your compensation. The insurance company will process the payment once the settlement agreement is finalized and signed. This compensation should cover your medical expenses, repair costs, and any other losses resulting from the accident. Receiving this payment marks the conclusion of the settlement process, allowing you to move forward from the incident.

Should I Consider Legal Representation?

You can handle the settlement process alone, but having a lawyer can bring big benefits. A car accident lawyer can protect your rights throughout the process and work to ensure that you receive a fair settlement. Skilled lawyers know insurance companies’ tactics to pay less and negotiate well for you. They handle legal work and let you focus on healing.

What Are the Important Timelines?

Awareness of the statute of limitations for filing a lawsuit is important if you cannot reach a settlement. This time frame varies by state but generally ranges from one to four years from the date of the accident. Missing this deadline can forfeit your right to pursue compensation through the courts.

A car accident lawyer can explain the timelines for your personal injury case. They will take all necessary action quickly to protect your claim.

What Documentation Should I Keep?

Keeping detailed records related to the accident and your injuries is advised. To support your claim, gather medical records, receipts, and insurance correspondence. Organize them well. This evidence shows the accident’s impact, helping you negotiate for a fair settlement.

Should I Accept the Initial Settlement Offer?

Initial settlement offers from insurance companies may not fully reflect the value of your claim. It’s important to carefully review any offer with your lawyer before accepting.

Insurance companies often aim to settle claims quickly and for as little as possible. A quick settlement might not account for ongoing medical treatment or the full extent of your damages.

A car accident lawyer can assess the fairness of the offer and advise you on whether to accept or negotiate for a better settlement. Once you accept a settlement offer, you can’t ask for more money later. It’s important to decide carefully.

William Pemberton, Personal Injury Lawyer
William Pemberton, Car Accident Lawyer

Contact a Car Accident Lawyer

While getting fair compensation for your injuries and damages can seem overwhelming, knowing what to expect can help alleviate some of the stress and uncertainty.

If you have questions or need assistance, seek legal advice from a personal injury attorney to protect your interests and ensure a fair resolution for your case.

Related Articles

Can I Get a Settlement for a Car Accident Without a Lawyer?

Read More

Is It Illegal To Wear Headphones While Driving in Wisconsin?

Read More

Is Wisconsin a No-Fault Insurance State?

Read More